1st Amendment lawyer weighs in on new Florida regulation banning protests at households

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – Individuals who protest in front of non-public households in Florida can confront jail time and fines beneath a new invoice signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis on Monday.

The governor explained the monthly bill would avert protests in Florida like “those waged by abortion rights protesters in front of U.S. Supreme Court docket justices’ homes in Virginia.”

Beginning Oct. 1, protesting in entrance of personal residences will develop into a second-diploma misdemeanor in Florida.

Beneath this monthly bill, this style of protesting will classify as “intentionally harassing or disturbing someone in their home.”

The new bill is receiving pushback from opposing sides stating it violates cost-free speech.

Legal professional Edward Birk, who specializes in To start with Amendment legislation, said that may well not be correct.

“Yes, it can be authorized underneath the constitution. Every single of us is entitled to be left alone in our residences and not issue to offensive speech or speech that we may possibly find offensive,” Birk said.


Violators can face 60 days in jail and fines of up to $500.

Protesters can only be arrested soon after disregarding law enforcement’s orders to disperse.

Even protesting on a community sidewalk outside a personal residence could fall into this category.

“The notion in this article is that (if) somebody’s protesting on a sidewalk, downtown somewhere, if a passerby finds that speech to be offensive, they can just hold going for walks and not pay back attention to it. But here, the person who the speech is directed to — the resident of a residence — is a lot more or fewer captive and shouldn’t have to flee their household to prevent offensive speech,” Birk stated.

In an electronic mail to news organizations, DeSantis referred to abortion rights demonstrators who protested outdoors of Supreme Court docket justices’ properties in Virginia as an “unruly mob.”

“Sending unruly mobs to private residences, like we have observed with the offended crowds in front of the residences of Supreme Court docket justices, is inappropriate. This invoice will present security to individuals residing in household communities and I am happy to signal it into legislation,” DeSantis explained.


Information4JAX attained out to Women’s March Jacksonville, an abortion legal rights group about their consider on the bill.

“Where do you draw that line? If this is a essential American correct and we begin to strip absent pieces of it…that’s a pretty slippery slope,” mentioned Dana Holland, Vice President of Women’s March Jacksonville.

We’ve also arrived at out to Jacksonville For Existence an anti-abortion corporation. The group did not reply.

Birk mentioned he expects lawsuits to problem the invoice. He claimed the two means it will be challenged will be based mostly on how the statute is created and how it is used and enforced.

Copyright 2022 by WJXT Information4JAX – All legal rights reserved.